The big news story of the day is abortion. When big stories break that consume all the news programs, you need to watch the news more closely. Politicians see big news stories as distractions, so they do things they might not do otherwise and hope nobody notices.
Abortion is a complex issue that I wanted to think about
more before I wrote anything. A
newspaper columnist today says that we need to talk about abortion. We have pickets and protests on both sides of
the issue, but we are not talking about the issue. And this is what we need to do.
People are concerned today that the ‘right’ to an abortion
may be lost. I put the word ‘right’ in
single quotes, because this is one of the points that the debate about abortion
falls on.
Is it actually a right?
People often conflate the legality of something with a
right. It’s legal to turn right on a red
light in most cases, but it is not a right.
If you believe that abortion should be legal, because it is a right,
then we need to talk about that.
Rights often imply too that the government, meaning
taxpayers, is required to either pay for or subsidize that thing. When tens of millions of people believe that
abortion is murder, no, they should not be required to pay for them. Now THAT is imposing your beliefs on society.
But what is a right?
There are three kinds of rights, but only two that concern
us here.
The Declaration of Independence says that our nation is
founded on the fact, not the belief but the fact, that God gave unalienable
rights to human beings. Unalienable
rights precede and supersede government such that government did not give them
and government cannot take them away.
The Constitution does not explicitly discuss abortion, so
the Court decided that the Fourth Amendment, which protects people against
unreasonable searches and seizures. gave people a right to privacy which would
encompass a right to abortion.
But does that mean I have a right to kill small animals or
watch kiddie porn in the privacy of my own home? This ‘right to privacy’ is not a solid foundation
for a ‘right’ to abortion.
It is often touted that a woman has a right to autonomy over
her own body. Her body, her choice. And I would agree. Yet these same people will insist that
everybody get vaccinated with drugs that many people believe to have more and
serious problems than what they are meant to solve. Here society, read government, feels empowered
to override your personal beliefs and autonomy to impose their will for the
sake of the greater good.
At least be consistent.
The problem here too is whether this thing growing inside
the woman is actually part of HER body or somebody else.
The question that needs to be discussed is what exactly is
this thing that we want so hard to kill.
We insist so hard that we are a secular society, that religion
has no place in a secular society, at least in the public square and in public
policy.
Except that there are questions that secularism cannot
answer
Like what is the value of a human life. True secular societies, like communist ones,
have no value of human life. It is
easily expendable for the greater, the common good. It is religion, specifically Christianity
with its teaching that human beings are created in the image of God, where
human life is deemed valuable, even precious.
In the creation account in the Bible, God creates animals
and fills the world with them. But when
ir comes to human beings, He creates only one.
And from that one, He forms a mate for it, and then from those two, all
future human beings created in the image of God come from human choices and
actions and not from God. We share God’s
creative activity.
Now society, and including government, may not be permitted
to take such things into consideration, but when half the country believes in
this, you can’t just tell them to shove it.
We need to have the discussion about what this thing we want
to kill is, and, yes, that discussion will have to talk about God. But our society, including government, doesn’t
want to have that discussion. Then this
division, this contentious division in our country, is not going to go
away.
Let’s
ask this again.
Is abortion a Constitutional right?
What is a Constitutional right in the first place? Our country was founded on the idea of rights,
and it is the Declaration of Independence, not the Constitution, that defines
these rights.
One of those basic human rights is the right to life.
So when does this child get this right to life?
When we say so? When
the government says so? When the mother
says so?
Then how is this an unalienable right, when other people can
confer it or deny it? If we cannot agree
on when this child receives this right to life, then we have no business taking
that child’s life.
Kathy Barnette is running for Senate in Pennsylvania. Her mother conceived her when she was
11. She had been raped by a 21 year old
man. Her mother’s mother just took her
into their family.
Ask her about the value of human life. She is happy to tell you.
No, life is not easy.
And pregnancy can complicate things very quickly. But children are not puppies or kittens in a
litter that we can just flush down a toilet.
We can find other solutions than just killing the child, and we need
to.