The city of Chicago is wondering what to do with statues of people they find problematic, like some of our former Presidents.
They asked for public comments, so these are mine.
My biggest concern with the monument issue is that it is
being driven by emotion rather than calm thinking. The entire legislative process in our country
is based on two houses of Congress. If
all we needed was the majority of opinion at any one time to drive our
policymaking decisions, we would only need one chamber. We have two, to slow down the process of
change, so that there are fewer chances of making a less than optimal
decision.
I suspect that we are making too much of this issue. Statues are not objects of worship. They represent pieces of our history. We have statues of Michael Jordan and Ernie
Banks at some of our Chicago sports arena.
They are not honored for living perfect human lives but for being
memorable athletes who millions of people enjoyed watching. The statues are not nor are meant to be validations
of their entire lives.
The issue that got this whole thing going is slavery.
I have argued in other contexts that in a slave society, the
kindest, most compassionate thing a person could do for the people being sold
into slavery could be to acquire as many of them as possible.
Why?
You can’t send them back.
Are you going to send them back on the same boats that brought them over
here?
There is no point in just freeing them. Where would they go? Somebody else would just enslave them
again.
But you could educate them, teach them a trade, and prepare
them for the day they could live free.
And more than that, you could treat them kindly, which may not be the
case anywhere else.
When we condemn people for the mere fact of slave ownership without
knowing anything more about them, then I think we show our shortsightedness and
failure to grasp history.
I think there are elements in our society who want to obliterate
any sense of pride in our country. They
want to make people unwilling to defend our nation and its ideals. They want to fundamentally change our country
in ways that you wouldn’t like if you could see them.
Yes, slavery was an evil practice, though it existed
throughout history throughout the world.
I ask the question though: if it had not been for slavery, all their
descendants today would still be living in Africa. So what country in Africa today would they
wish they were living in? I submit that
America, with any and all of its faults, is still the best place in the world
to live today.
In the Bible, God’s chosen people were led by God into Egypt
where they were to become slaves. God had
His chosen servant, Joseph, sold into slavery so that God could use him for His
purposes.
No, America is not perfect, but I think it is unwise to
constantly belittle our past, thinking that we are going to make our future
better for it.
When we dismiss our past, we end up not seeing what good
there is here, not knowing what our country is all about, and ultimately
destroying the freest and most prosperous country ever to exist in the world.